Dana ranks in the top ten brokers in the nation for Sotheby's International Realty.
"The true sign of a leader is someone you want to follow. I worked with Dana in 2007 to buy a house and again recently to sell that house. Both experiences were fantastic and without question would work with her again. We met in 2006 as I began to ..."
"We were put in touch with Dana by a New York City real estate broker and friend, who recommended her unreservedly. The recommendation was well deserved. Dana listened carefully and quickly got a sense of our tastes and preferences, and she chose s..."
"My wife and I have been working with Dana Trotter as our family's Broker since 2006. She helped us find our first rental back then and over the past decade plus she has helped us buy and sell three other homes from $2M - $4M plus. Dana has been an..."
One of Sagaponack Village's first summer homes and an early progenitor of the classic Hamptons shingle-style, "Winnecoma" was built in 1899, by John Sherlock of Ohio with the Manhattan architecture firm James Ware and Sons, as a summer estate and horse farm. Today, the bucolic 4± acre compound, n...
$18,500,000
Price9
Beds8
Baths6,618
Sq.Ft.
Set on a manicured 0.60+/- acre waterfront parcel on a secluded Bay Point peninsula with dramatic water views of Sag Harbor Village, this recently built and immaculately maintained, 6 bedroom, white shingle traditional, with a stylish, standing seam metal roof, offers a 115+/- foot deep water doc...
$10,750,000
Price6
Beds6.5
Baths6,500
Sq.Ft.
Perched above Sag Harbor Cove with commanding west-facing views of Noyack Bay for magical sunsets, this waterfront new construction in Sag Harbor's desirable Bay Point offers a stunning 5,400 square foot, 5 bedroom, 7.5 bath home with a waterside pool, sumptuous outdoor spaces including 1900 squa...
$6,500,000
Price5
Beds8
Baths5,400
Sq.Ft.
A tour de force of luxury design by boutique builder David Rimland of Rimland Construction and Hunt Architecture, this custom 5 bedroom, 4910 square foot North Haven home with a heated gunite pool, exceptional outdoor spaces, and a finished lower level with gym and sauna is offered for sale pre-c...
$5,995,000
Price5
Beds5.5
Baths4,910
Sq.Ft.
In the heart of historic Sag Harbor Village, this stunning new construction project will produce a 5,012 square foot, three story, 6 bedroom, 6.5 bath shingled traditional with an attached garage, heated, gunite pool, and 12 x 16 foot pool house on a generous 0.51 ± acre parcel. A compelli...
$5,750,000
Price6
Beds6.5
Baths5,012
Sq.Ft.
Sheltered by mature trees and exquisite landscaping on a rare 0.73+/- acre oasis in Sag Harbor Village, this recently renovated 4-bedroom turnkey home features a heated gunite pool, attached two-car garage, and open kitchen with easy flow to the al fresco dining patio. The home opens to a formal ...
$3,495,000
Price4
Beds4.5
Baths3,889
Sq.Ft.
Across the street from Gardiner's Bay with a private trail to East Hampton's Barnes Landing Beach for residents, this cheery four bedroom Techbuilt style home features lovely outdoor spaces and a heated, gunite pool nestled on a beautifully landscaped acre. The airy and elevated living room, dini...
$2,500,000
Price4
Beds2
Baths1,800
Sq.Ft.
Minutes from the charms of East Hampton Village's Main Street and world renowned ocean beaches, this 0.63 acre buildable lot presents a rare opportunity to create a dream home in the village's fabled lanes. Renovate and expand the existing Cape style home or build anew. Exceptional nearby sold pr...
$2,140,000
Price
July: $275,000; September 7-30 $175,000 Feet from the hallowed links of the Maidstone Club and less than a mile from Egypt Beach, a private 2.0+/-acre compound unfolds at the end of a long gated drive on East Hampton's famed Egypt Lane. The 6 bedroom, 7.5 bath main house, designed by Alexander Go...
$275,000/mo
Price6
Beds10
Baths8,800
Sq.Ft.
August (Two Weeks) $65,000 Minutes from East Hampton Village on a gated and beautifully landscaped 1.5 acres, this impeccably furnished 6 bedroom traditional offers a heated, gunite pool and spa, lovely outdoor spaces, a chef's kitchen, and finished lower level. EH RR #: 22-528
$175,000/mo
Price6
Beds7,000
Sq.Ft.
Set in Sag Harbor Village's desirable Redwood Island neighborhood with water views, this 5 bedroom new construction of impeccable craftsmanship and style by artisan builder David Rimland features an open concept layout awash with natural light, finished lower level with gym and walkout terrace, h...
$150,000/mo
Price5
Beds6
Baths
July $125,000; August-LD $140,000; July-LD - $265,000; Weekly - $30,000; June $60,000Set in the revered Amagansett lanes a stone's throw to ocean beaches and town, this pristine 4 bedroom, 4.5 bath immaculately maintained, shingled traditional features an open floor pla...
$150,000/mo
Price4
Beds4.5
Baths4,400
Sq.Ft.
June: $150,000; July $220,000; August-LD $225,000 Sheltered on 4.85 beautifully landscaped acres with sunset views of Poxabogue Pond, this immaculately appointed 6 bedroom traditional offers exceptional outdoor amenities with a sunken tennis court combo with pickle-ball court and basketball hoops...
$150,000/mo
Price6
Beds7
Baths9,000
Sq.Ft.
June $70,000; August - Labor Day: $150,000 Offering stunning views across farmland to Mecox Bay and the Atlantic Ocean, this stylish 4 bedroom shingled traditional with a terraced bluestone patio, heated gunite pool and spa, and two car garage is located deep in Water Mill South near Bridgehampto...
$150,000/mo
Price4
Beds4.5
Baths3,600
Sq.Ft.
July - Labor Day: $250,000; July $100,000; August (LD) $135,000 Deep in Water Mill South, bordering Bridgehampton, around the corner from ocean beaches and award-winning farm stands, this designer owned traditional features voluminous and richly textured interiors that weave into sumptuous outdoo...
$135,000/mo
Price4
Beds3.5
Baths5,700
Sq.Ft.
April: $8,000 per month; May $20,000; MD-LD $120,000; July-LD $100,000; June $25,000; July $45,000; August (LD) $60,000; September $25,000 Perched on a secluded 1.54 acres sheltered by mature landscaping, this exceedingly stylish, designer-finished four bedroom Cape has magical outdoor spaces set...
$120,000/mo
Price4
Beds3
Baths3,200
Sq.Ft.
August (LD) $100,000; July $90,000; July-LD $180,000 Minutes from Bridgehampton’s famed barns, polo grounds, and the Hampton Classic, this designer coastal tropical style 5 bedroom home has all the amenities for summer in the Hamptons including exceptional outdoor spaces with a heated, guni...
$100,000/mo
Price5
Beds6.5
Baths7,500
Sq.Ft.
July $80,000 Recently renovated by notable architect, Kitty McCoy, this 5-bedroom, 4-bath home in Wainscott South is short distance to local farmstands and ocean beaches. This original 1812 school house has been sympathetically renovated to preserve the historic charm, and incorporate today's mod...
$100,000/mo
Price5
Beds3,800
Sq.Ft.
August (LD) $85,000; July $85,000; July-LD $170,000 In the heart of Sag Harbor Village, this beautifully renovated and stylishly designed 4 bedroom home with a heated, gunite pool has historic character and modern functionality. New and exclusive rental offering with Dana Trotter of Sotheby's Int...
$85,000/mo
Price4
Beds3.5
Baths2,700
Sq.Ft.
Minutes from East Hampton Village, this stylishly renovated 6 bedroom, 5600 square foot contemporary home offers open concept living with soaring ceilings and exceptional indoor outdoor flow with a screened porch and expansive decking leading to the heated gunite pool. The amenities check all the...
$80,000/mo
Price6
Beds6
Baths5,600
Sq.Ft.
Be the first to enjoy this four bedroom, two bathroom home which has just completed a full renovation and is ready for summer enjoyment. Located just a stone's throw from Circle Beach in Pine Neck, Sag Harbor's classic summer colony. This stylish, completely renovated four bedroom, two bathroom h...
$75,000/mo
Price4
Beds2
Baths2,160
Sq.Ft.
March-April $8,000; May $15,000; June $35,000; July-LD $150,000; July $75,000; August-LD $90,000; MD-LD $175,000; March-LD $200,000; September $15,000; October $10,000 With sweeping views of Accabonac Harbor, this recently renovated 1960s Modernist style home, designed and decorated by Meyer Davi...
$75,000/mo
Price4
Beds4
Baths2,800
Sq.Ft.
MD-June $65,000; September $50,000 Set on a manicured 0.60+/- acre waterfront parcel on a secluded Bay Point peninsula with dramatic water views of Sag Harbor Village, this recently built and immaculately maintained, 6 bedroom, white shingle traditional, with a stylish, standing seam metal roof, ...
$65,000/mo
Price6
Beds7
Baths6,500
Sq.Ft.
July $55,000 Rental Registration #22-486. Light and bright, this recently renovated beach house overlooks reserve and offers 4 +/- acres of privacy. Features include a double height living room with fireplace, dining room, open kitchen with breakfast room, 4 bedrooms (including a first floor mast...
$55,000/mo
Price4
Beds3.5
Baths3,000
Sq.Ft.
August (LD) $45,000 Short Term $10,000 Overlooking Upper Sag Harbor Cove with an expansive waterside deck and dock, this beautifully renovated 3 bedroom in the Redwood neighborhood of Sag Harbor Village is secluded yet convenient to the charms of Main Street. New and exclusive rental offering wit...
$45,000/mo
Price3
Beds2
Baths1,276
Sq.Ft.
April $7,000; May $10,000; June $15,000; September $15,000; October $7,000; MD-LD $75,000; July-LD $65,000; August-LD $35,000; July $30,000 Perched on a secluded 1.6 acre property around the corner from Round Swamp Farm and minutes to East Hampton Village, this recently renovated 4 bedroom midcen...
$35,000/mo
Price4
Beds2.5
Baths1,600
Sq.Ft.
December-June $4,900 per month Conveniently located in Sagaponack North around the corner from a record-setting sale, this charming 3 bedroom farmhouse with a wraparound porch is tucked away on a mostly cleared 0.55 acre parcel with room for a pool. An updated kitchen with stainless appliances, s...
$20,000/mo
Price3
Beds2.5
Baths2,146
Sq.Ft.It’s laid back but no less beautiful than its counterparts, the cool kid of the Hamptons.
Read More
Bridgehampton is known for horse farms, auto racing, and the Bridgehampton loam.
Read More
East Hampton's Main Street and tree-lined lanes are dotted with preserved homes spanning several eras and styles.
Read More
Montauk enjoys unsurpassed ocean vistas and a natural serenity set amongst a vibrant town.
Read More
The most expensive zip code, combination of farm field vistas and beach vibes.
Read More
Sag Harbor is pure classic, it has the quaint, good ol' main street vibe down pat.
Read More
Shelter Island has the slow pace and unmistakable historic charm of a bygone era.
Read More
The Southampton's estate section is matched with equally renown beaches.
Read More
Minutes from East Hampton Village, soak in the history of Springs at the Pollack-Krasner House.
Read More
A beachy throwback where original farmhouses, dot Wainscott Main Street.
Read More
Water Mill has possibly the most geographical diversity of any Hamptons hamlet.
Read More
Browse my notable press mentions below.
The streets of Los Angeles are strewn with a variety of lavish estates, from glorious Old World–inspired manors with roots in Hollywood’s golden er...
read more
Showcasing the height of new luxury construction in some of the world’s most sought after locations, explore an exclusive new development from our...
read more
Sturdy and stately, brick residences can trace their origins back to 3500 B.C., when the first fired brick allowed for the creation of permanent s...
read moreDana's portfolio includes high-end residential sales and rentals as well as investment and land opportunities. She has successfully negotiated hundreds of property contracts and continues to work vigorously for buyers and sellers alike.
Let's Connect