Welcome to Shelter Island
Entering by way of its distinctive ferry, Shelter Island has the slow pace and unmistakable historic charm of a bygone era. Stunning water views, bayfront beaches, five star restaurants, art galleries, antique stores, and exceptional boating and fishing opportunities make Shelter Island a favorite destination minutes from the Hamptons and just a few hours from New York City. Shelter Island real estate for sale is generally luxurious and beautifully designed with close proximity to the coast.
Population: 2,411
Average Sale Price 2019: $1,538,138
Favorite Restaurant: Vine Street Cafe
Don’t Miss: Mashomuck Preserve
Learn about other neighborhoods:
Where to Stay in Amagansett
Where to Play in Amagansett
- Beach Info
- ​​​​​​​Golf or Tennis Anyone
- ​​​​​​​Gym
- ​​​​​​​Summer Camp for the Kids
- ​​​​​​​Horses
- ​​​​​​​Salon or Spa
- ​​​​​​​Where to Shop
- ​​​​​​​Arts and Museum
- ​​​​​​​Wine, Vin, Vino
- ​​​​​​​Farm Stands
- ​​​​​​​Groceries
- Concierge/ Chef/ Babysitter/ Medical