My Team

Our Team

Primary phone
(631) 379-3236
Email
[email protected]

Get to Know Us

After 27 years at Sotheby’s International Realty and over $1 billion in sales in the Hamptons market, Dana Trotter joined The Agency as a partner to open its first office in the Hamptons.

Widely regarded as one of the area's top agents, Dana ranked among the top 10 brokers in the nation company wide and in the top 50 of the REAL Trends/Wall Street Journal's esteemed annual rankings.

She joins Agency founder and CEO Mauricio Umansky and Tyler Whitman, star of Bravo’s Million Dollar Listing, to launch the Agency in Bridgehampton in the summer of 2023. The Agency is one of the fastest-growing boutique brokerage brands in the world and was named the Top Luxury Brokerage by Inman.

Dana's portfolio includes high-end residential sales and rentals as well as investment and land opportunities. She has successfully negotiated hundreds of property contracts and continues to work vigorously for buyers and sellers alike.

Prior to entering the world of real estate, Dana completed a BA in business marketing and accounting from CW Post and competed professionally in equestrian events both in New York and Palm Beach.

She has competed in the Hampton Classic since the age of eight, and rides her horse, Balou, every chance she gets. Sharing the transformative power of horses, Dana is on the boards of the non-profit Center For Therapeutic Riding on the East End (CTREE) and the Long Island University (LIU) Veterinary School.

Dana lives in Sagaponack with her husband, three kids, two dogs, cat, and flock of chickens.

Learn more

Shane Donahue
Licensed Sales Person
After a decade at Sotheby’s International Realty contributing to over half a billion dollars in sales volume, Shane...
- Call
- Email

No results found.

What My Clients Say

The true sign of a leader is someone you want to follow. I worked with Dana in 2007 to buy a house and again recently to sell that house. Both experiences were fantastic and without question would work with her again. We met in 2006 as I began to explore purchasing in Southampton. Dana was very patient with me, got to know me and my changing needs, and made it a point of giving me a great education on the market and locations. I don't remember...

~ David
What My Clients Say

We were put in touch with Dana by a New York City real estate broker and friend, who recommended her unreservedly. The recommendation was well deserved. Dana listened carefully and quickly got a sense of our tastes and preferences, and she chose suitable properties for us to view. The process went smoothly from beginning to end. We couldn't have been more pleased and now look forward to many happy years in our new home.

~ Buyer
What My Clients Say

My wife and I have been working with Dana Trotter as our family's Broker since 2006. She helped us find our first rental back then and over the past decade plus she has helped us buy and sell three other homes from $2M - $4M plus. Dana has been an absolute rockstar broker and dear family friend and we could not give her a higher recommendation.

~ Kerry
What My Clients Say

Dana has been the consummate professional in all of our transactions from the sale of our North Haven home to the purchase of a new Sag Harbor property. She is responsive day and night, honest, ethical and a delight to deal with. Truly a straight shooter who only wants what's best for her customer. Stellar!

~ Buyer | Seller
What My Clients Say

Dana is an absolute pleasure. She knows the location and market inside and out, and was a great partner in helping us find our dream home. We couldn't recommend her more!

~ Greg
What My Clients Say

Dana is one of the top performing agents in the Hamptons. She holds the highest standards of professionalism with her clients. I highly recommend her.

~ Tye
What My Clients Say

Dana, Shane, and Team, your command of negotiation and the representation of a property is truly remarkable. Your intuitive approach to selling my home impressed me and redefined my real estate experience. I'm grateful beyond words for your exceptional work; your excellence knows no bounds. With heartfelt thanks!

~ Seller