31 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Firefly Alley

Firefly Alley

31 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY


  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Full Baths
  • 1 Half Bath
  • 0.62 Acres Lot
  • 1,203 Sq.Ft. Living
  • For Lease Status

August-LD $20,000; July $20,000; September $12,0000

Located in the center of Shelter Island a short distance from Sylvester Manor Farmstand, Whale’s Tail Mini Golf, shopping and dining, this newly built 2 bedroom cottage was designed and furnished by Heiberg Cummings. Inviting outdoor spaces maximize the views of the rear 24 acre wooded preserve with walking trails. 

With a vaulted ceiling clad in shiplap, an airy living room leads to a gourmet kitchen with center island seating, Bosch appliance line. The kitchen opens to the elevated, rear dining deck with a lovely view of the preserve. 

The stylish bath has a soaking tub, designer matte black fixtures, cast concrete basin, and floating, tankless Duravit toilet.

Built with sustainability in mind, this solar home by GreenLogic has battery backup, spray foam insulation, and runs energy efficient, electric appliances. Smart home features include Nest thermostats and smoke+CO detectors, and the Nest Yale lock. With a consideration for indoor air quality, the home is outfitted with an induction range and ERV. Whole house water filtration and reverse osmosis filtration.

Chatham 7-speed Beach Cruiser bikes with handwoven baskets to explore Shelter Island. Tesla wall charger in the garage.

Show MoreShow Less

Features and Amenities


  • Total Bedrooms2
  • Full Bathrooms2
  • Half Bathrooms1

Area & Lot

  • Status For Lease
  • Living Area1,203 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area0.62 Acres


Dana's portfolio includes high-end residential sales and rentals as well as investment and land opportunities. She has successfully negotiated hundreds of property contracts and continues to work vigorously for buyers and sellers alike.

Let's Connect
Follow Dana