119 Bay Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Nantucket-Style Coastal Elegance

Nantucket-Style Coastal Elegance

119 Bay Street, Sag Harbor, NY

$5,250,000

HIGHLIGHTS
  • 4 Beds
  • 5 Full Baths
  • 0.2 Acres Lot
  • 4,200 Sq.Ft. Living
  • 2016 Year Built
  • Sold Status
  • 927832 MLS® ID

Perfectly positioned on the waterside of Sag Harbor Village’s coveted Bay Street, this meticulously maintained Nantucket-style residence blends timeless coastal charm with modern luxury. Just moments from Havens Beach and a short distance to the marina and Sag Harbor Yacht Club, the home offers four bedrooms, five baths, and a thoughtful three-level layout designed for effortless village living. Past the welcoming front porch, the entry foyer opens to sun-filled interiors anchored by a wood-burning fireplace and a dining area with coffered ceilings. The eat-in kitchen, appointed with Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances, counter seating, and a casual breakfast area, flows seamlessly to the heated gunite pool and beautifully landscaped grounds by Nievera Williams Design, creating an exceptional setting for both intimate gatherings and large-scale entertaining.

Upstairs, the serene primary suite overlooks the rear gardens and features a gas fireplace, a custom California Closets walk-in, and a spa-caliber bath with a freestanding tub and steam shower. Three generous guest bedrooms and two full baths complete the level. The fully finished lower level includes bonus recreation space, a full bath, and a dedicated gym, further enhancing the home’s versatility.

A rare opportunity to own a turnkey village beach house with refined finishes, smart-home amenities, seamless indoor-outdoor living, and effortless access to the very best of Sag Harbor.

Show MoreShow Less
Dana Trotter

Dana Trotter

Managing Partner The Agency Hamptons
Phone

631-379-3236

Shane Donahue

Shane Donahue

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Phone

510-333-3317

Features and Amenities

Interior

  • Total Bedrooms4
  • Total Bathrooms5
  • Full Bathrooms5

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Living Area4,200 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area0.2 Acres
  • MLS® ID927832
  • TypeResidential
  • YEAR BUILT2016
  • neighborhoodSag Harbor
  • LifestylesBeach, Waterfront
  • Architecture StylesColonial
  • water FrontageBay

Exterior

  • STORIES2
  • Water SourceTown Water
  • PoolYes
  • parkingOff Street
  • HEAT TYPECentral A/c
  • AIR CONDITIONINGHVAC

Financial

  • Sales Price$5,250,000
  • Real Estate Tax $17,836/yr

Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor is pure classic, it has the quaint, good ol' main street vibe down pat.

Sag Harbor

WORK WITH DANA

Dana's portfolio includes high-end residential sales and rentals as well as investment and land opportunities. She has successfully negotiated hundreds of property contracts and continues to work vigorously for buyers and sellers alike.

Let's Connect
Follow Dana